Expressions of affinial kinship and social support among high school extracurricular activities
Class
Article
Graduation Year
2017
College
College of Humanities and Social Sciences
Department
Sociology, Social Work & Anthropology Department
Faculty Mentor
Travis Dorsch
Presentation Type
Oral Presentation
Abstract
The present descriptive research highlights the social networks and support systems in high school extracurricular activities and how they arise. Phase I of the research was designed to assess the differences in sense of community among different forms of high school extracurricualrs: competitive groups (e.g., athletic teams, marching band); performance groups (e.g., choir, orchestra); and participatory groups (e.g., language clubs, science clubs). A total of 701 students completed surveys tapping student perceptions of sense of community, commitment, and enjoyment in their respective activities. Students who participated in performance groups had significantly lower sense of community scores than members of competitive and participatory groups. This is likely due to the compulsory nature of the entry level groups included in the sample; students who take these classes because they are mandatory to graduate may not do so because they are committed to or enjoy their activity. Phase II of the research was designed to assess student perceptions of the development of sense of community among group members. A subsample of 18 students from Phase I participated in semi-structured interviews. Interviews were transcribed and cross-checked for accuracy, then coded thematically using MAXQDA. Analyses suggest that many students have feelings of pride when their group works toward or accomplishes a common goal. Additionally, many students likened their group to a family, ascribing kinship terms to coaches, faculty, and peers. Participants also expressed feelings of trust towards both their instructors and their peers, stating that they'd be willing to go to either if they had personal problems. Despite these general findings, stark differences arise between higher- and lower-level groups within the same school, particularly when students perceive favoritism by the instructor, or when a significant number of students are involved in a sub-group, leaving a smaller proportion out of the activity or event.
Location
Room 421
Start Date
4-13-2017 1:30 PM
End Date
4-13-2017 2:45 PM
portrait
Expressions of affinial kinship and social support among high school extracurricular activities
Room 421
The present descriptive research highlights the social networks and support systems in high school extracurricular activities and how they arise. Phase I of the research was designed to assess the differences in sense of community among different forms of high school extracurricualrs: competitive groups (e.g., athletic teams, marching band); performance groups (e.g., choir, orchestra); and participatory groups (e.g., language clubs, science clubs). A total of 701 students completed surveys tapping student perceptions of sense of community, commitment, and enjoyment in their respective activities. Students who participated in performance groups had significantly lower sense of community scores than members of competitive and participatory groups. This is likely due to the compulsory nature of the entry level groups included in the sample; students who take these classes because they are mandatory to graduate may not do so because they are committed to or enjoy their activity. Phase II of the research was designed to assess student perceptions of the development of sense of community among group members. A subsample of 18 students from Phase I participated in semi-structured interviews. Interviews were transcribed and cross-checked for accuracy, then coded thematically using MAXQDA. Analyses suggest that many students have feelings of pride when their group works toward or accomplishes a common goal. Additionally, many students likened their group to a family, ascribing kinship terms to coaches, faculty, and peers. Participants also expressed feelings of trust towards both their instructors and their peers, stating that they'd be willing to go to either if they had personal problems. Despite these general findings, stark differences arise between higher- and lower-level groups within the same school, particularly when students perceive favoritism by the instructor, or when a significant number of students are involved in a sub-group, leaving a smaller proportion out of the activity or event.